Episode 558: Why Smart Organizations Keep Doing Dumb Things (Premium Preview)

Play video preview episode | Play audio-only preview episode | Play on YouTube | Play on Spotify

Episode Summary

Sara Gallagher returns to examine a frustrating reality for project managers: organizations can employ smart, experienced, well-intentioned people and still produce the same bad outcomes again and again. Sara, president of The Persimmon Group and creator of the Big Dumb Questions newsletter, brings more than 15 years of consulting experience to a discussion that starts with artificial intelligence and quickly expands into how organizations make decisions, manage transitions, respond to change, and structure project leadership. She explains how she separates work into simple, complicated, and complex categories when deciding what to give AI, and why simple and selected complicated work offer the most practical opportunities today. From there, Sara and Cornelius examine decision latency and the danger of judging a decision only by its eventual outcome. Sara argues that leaders should focus on whether they made a defensible decision based on the information and criteria available at the time. They also examine project handoffs, where weak preparation can allow value to leak away and risk to increase just as the project reaches a critical transition point.

The conversation then turns to people and behavior. Sara challenges the tendency to confuse confidence with competence when organizations hire and promote people, drawing partly on her own career experience. She also explains why motivated teams can resist organizational change even when leaders communicate clearly and provide training. People make hundreds of small, rational decisions every day, and Sara suggests that three questions shape many of those choices: What is valuable? What is easy? What is safe? Project managers and change leaders can improve adoption by designing the project environment around those questions rather than relying only on more communication, training, or auditing.

Finally, Sara considers how AI may reshape the project management profession itself. As AI handles more coordination work, organizations may place greater value on project managers with strong business knowledge, risk awareness, strategic judgment, and the ability to manage related initiatives with greater accountability. That shift may also challenge traditional ideas about influence without authority and the project manager who simply moves from one temporary project to another. Sara closes with a practical diagnostic approach: instead of blaming people when projects struggle, examine the system around them. Look at people, process, tools, culture, and team structure, then ask what the organization may be doing to encourage the behavior it wants to change.

In This Episode, You Will Learn:

• Using AI for project work - How Sara separates simple, complicated, and complex work when deciding what AI should handle and where human judgment still matters.
• Making decisions under uncertainty - Why leaders should judge decisions by the quality of the reasoning and criteria behind them rather than simply by the outcome.
• Improving project handoffs - How a Project Field Guide and a structured transition agenda can protect project value, reduce risk, and help incoming project managers gain context faster.
• Understanding human behavior and change resistance - Why people make rational micro-decisions based on what feels valuable, easy, and safe, and how project managers can design change with those factors in mind.
• Preparing for the changing project manager role - Why AI may increase the importance of business acumen, risk management, strategic judgment, and longer-term accountability for project outcomes.

Resources Mentioned

• Big Dumb Questions - Sara Gallagher's newsletter examines the questions organizations often avoid asking about strategy, execution, projects, and organizational behavior. https://saragallagher.com/big-dumb-questions/
• Project Hand-Off Tools - Sara's Project Field Guide and Transition Agenda support project managers who need to transfer project knowledge and responsibility to someone new. https://saragallagher.com/big-dumb-questions/why-are-we-still-terrible-at-project-hand-offs/
• The Momentum Map - The diagnostic Sara mentions near the end of the conversation helps leaders examine the organizational system behind execution problems. https://saragallagher.com/frameworks/momentum-map/
• Thinking in Bets by Annie Duke - Annie Duke uses the term "resulting" for the tendency to judge the quality of a decision by its outcome, the concept Sara references during the discussion about decision-making. https://www.annieduke.com/books/

Quotes from This Episode

• "Why does the system keep producing the same bad outcomes, even when everyone involved knows better?" - Cornelius Fichtner
• "Confidence is an asset. It's just an overappreciated one." - Sara Gallagher
• "It's always the system in which the work is getting done." - Sara Gallagher

Connect with Sara Gallagher

• LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/saraegallagher
• Website: https://saragallagher.com/

Time-Stamped Show Notes

• [00:25] - Why smart organizations keep producing bad outcomes despite having smart, capable people.
• [01:37] - Deciding what AI should handle by separating simple, complicated, and complex work.
• [07:19] - Making defensible decisions without judging their quality solely by the eventual outcome.
• [11:42] - Why project handoffs fail and how better transitions protect value and reduce risk.
• [16:54] - How organizations can mistake confidence for competence when hiring and promoting people.
• [22:43] - Understanding change resistance through the questions of what feels valuable, easy, and safe.
• [26:40] - How PMOs can build the business acumen project managers need to ask better questions.
• [28:13] - How AI may challenge influence without authority and push project managers toward more strategic roles.
• [32:01] - Why some project managers may leave as the profession moves toward deeper expertise and longer-term accountability.
• [35:25] - Stop blaming people: diagnose the system behind troubled projects and undesirable behavior.

For more of Sara Gallagher's Big Dumb Questions and the resources discussed in this conversation, visit https://pm-podcast.com/dumb.

Artificial Intelligence for Project Managers Course: